If Brexit is the answer, what is the question?

There is a view that leaving the European Union (EU) will solve this country’s problems. This is wrong on two counts; firstly leaving the EU does not in itself solve any problems, although it may create the frameworks within which solutions could be developed. Secondly leaving the EU creates a miriad of new problems. There may well be new opportunities offered by leaving the EU but do these really compensate for the downsides? Taken together this could leave us with all of the existing problems plus a raft of new social and

Let’s understand the problems first

economic problems.

So before deciding that leaving the EU is the answer we should surely try to understand what the problems are? Brexiteers had all sorts of reasons for voting leave, ranging from a protest vote driven by a desire for change, through immigration to “let’s make Britain great again”. There is no doubt that real problems exist in the UK today; a deep seated grievance at the stark inequalities that exist. Politicians have for a long time used the EU as a lazy excuse for these problems, blaming EU buereaucracy, institutions, policy for everything, instead of actually addressing the real problems here at home. I believe we must understand how leaving the EU is going to help us solve these problems otherwise how do we know we have the right negotiating priorities?

So what are the real problems we are trying to solve? Here’s a starter for ten based on some of the issues raised in the Brexit campaign that, according to Brexiteers, would be solved by leaving the EU:

  • The NHS and social care
  • Jobs and low wages
  • Housing
  • Inequality
  • Benefits of globalization not shared
  • School places and the quality of education
  • British culture under attack
  • Unnecessary regulation and bureaucracy
  • What else?

I suggest that leaving the EU will NOT solve any of these directly and, more importantly, they are all issues caused by the combined policies of a succession of British governments and have little or nothing to do with EU membership. I will explore each of these in future blogs.

One Reply to “If Brexit is the answer, what is the question?”

  1. I guess Terrorism and the perceived link to Immigration is the big one missing from the list.
    I think most Brexiteers firmly believe that terrorism is a huge threat to life and to their children’s lives despite it being a statistically tiny threat compared to the impact of many of the potential downsides of leaving the EU.
    I think the battle for Brexit starts by helping people see the tiny risk to their day-to-day lives from terrorism, but this is hard when the media coverage is so imbalanced.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *